Machine Score Is Not Proof of Cheating: CJI Surya Kant Urges Caution on AI Detectors
Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has cautioned law schools against treating artificial-intelligence detection software as conclusive proof of academic misconduct, warning that unreliable results could expose students to unfair accusations.
(By Syed Ali Taher Abedi)
Hyderabad,21, November,2026- Speaking at the Commonwealth Legal Education Association’s First Annual International Conference on Legal Education, 2026, in Hyderabad, the CJI said that a student should not face a finding of misconduct solely because a detection tool label submitted work as AI-generated.
His remarks addressed a growing concern among universities as generative AI becomes increasingly accessible to students.
“No student should therefore be held guilty of misconduct on the word of a machine alone.” CJI Surya Kant made the observation during his inaugural address at the Commonwealth Legal Education Association’s (CLEA) First Annual International Conference on Legal Education, 2026, in Hyderabad.
The CJI drew attention to research examining the reliability of AI-text detectors, including a 2023 study published in Patterns. Researchers tested seven detectors against 91 essays written by non-native English speakers and 88 essays by US school students.
The study reported that the tools, on average, incorrectly classified 61.3% of the TOEFL essays as AI-generated, while they performed far more accurately on the US students’ essays. The findings point to a risk that language patterns associated with non-native English writing may be mistaken for machine-generated text.
“In a Commonwealth where so many students write in English as a second or third language, an honest student could thus be branded a cheat on the strength of a number that no one can explain, and that student cannot meaningfully challenge. “He warned against using results from these tools as conclusive evidence of academic dishonesty.
That risk, the CJI observed, has particular significance in Commonwealth jurisdictions, where many students use English as a second or additional language.
An opaque score, he suggested, may be difficult for a student to understand or meaningfully contest.
The concern, therefore, is not simply whether institutions can detect AI use, but whether the evidence they rely on is sufficiently dependable to justify disciplinary consequences.
Turning to the broader place of AI in legal education, the CJI reportedly cautioned against an outright prohibition. Students entering the profession will encounter these technologies, he noted law schools should instead establish clear rules for their use and teach students to apply them responsibly. Students should know in advance which uses are permitted, when disclosure is required and when reliance on AI would undermine the skill an assessment is meant to evaluate.
“The question, therefore, is no longer whether students will use these tools, but whether the work they submit still reflects their own reasoning, understanding, and appreciation for the law.” The CJI noted that imposing an outright ban on AI tools is neither practical nor prudent, given that students will soon join a legal profession already utilizing them
He also urged institutions to reconsider how they assess student work. Written assignments, he suggested, could be complemented by oral questioning, discussion of the authorities cited, or exercises testing whether students can identify flaws in machine-generated answers. Such measures would focus on a student’s actual understanding rather than on a detector’s inference.
The central message from the address was one of caution: technology may assist academic evaluation, but an automated flag should not, on its own, determine a student’s academic fate.

